Our Menu
Authentic Italian dishes and pizza in Shirley, NY, made from family recipes since 1986.
Most Ordered
- Neapolitan (Large)$21.95
- Garlic Knots (Dozen)$7.25
- Regular Slice$3.35
- Salad Slice$7.60
- Chicken Wings (6)$8.30
- Pepperoni Wheel$3.70
- Sicilian Pie$24.80
- Neapolitan (Small)$17.00
- Meatball Parmigiana Hero$10.90
- Sicilian Slice$3.35
- Caesar Salad (Large)$10.80
- Penne alla Vodka$21.80
Pizza
Additional toppings: Small +$2.60 · Large +$3.65 · Sicilian +$4.15. Toppings: Extra Cheese, Peppers, Onions, Pepperoni, Meatball, Sausage, Mushroom, Anchovies, Eggplant, Garlic, Broccoli, White Pizza, Ham, Black Olives, Spinach, Salami, Prosciutto, Sun Dried Tomato.
- NeapolitanSmall $17.00 · Large $21.95
- Sicilian$24.80
- Deep Dish$26.10
Specialty Pies
House specialty pies include Bacon, Tomato, BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Parm, Chicken Marsala, Chicken Francese, Spinach White, Baked Ziti, and Thin Margarita.
- Grandma PizzaSicilian $26.80
- Capressi$34.76
- SpecialSmall $25.92 · Large $31.90 · Sicilian $34.76
- Salad PieSmall $27.47 · Large $32.94
- Stuffed Pizza (Meat or Veg)$32.55
- ShrimpSmall $26.44 · Large $35.54 · Sicilian $33.56
- Thick MargaritaSmall $23.32 · Large $32.85
- Greek SaladSmall $27.48 · Large $33.90
Pizza by the Slice
- Regular Slice$3.35
- Special Pie Slice$5.20
- Grandma Slice$4.25
- Sicilian Slice$3.35
- Stuffed Slice (Meat or Veg)$6.40
- Salad Slice$7.60
- Salad Slice with Chicken$8.50
Appetizers
- Baked Clams$11.85Seasoned with bread crumb, garlic & olive oil
- Clams Casino$12.45Seasoned with bell peppers, bacon, garlic & bread crumbs
- Fried Calamari$13.50Battered & deep fried, served with marinara sauce
- Zucchini Sticks$6.18Fresh zucchini sliced, breaded & fried to a golden brown, served with sauce
- Stuffed Mushrooms$12.45Seasoned and stuffed with crab meat, topped with mozzarella cheese
- Mussels Marinara or Bianco$12.45Sauteed in garlic, then simmered in your choice of sauce
- Broccoli Rabe$12.45Sauteed with sweet Italian sausage in garlic & oil
- Baked Ziti Balls$10.40Breaded and fried baked ziti covered in vodka sauce
- Hot Antipasto2 people $11.85 · 4 people $18.00Stuffed mushrooms, baked clams, fried calamari, and eggplant rollatini
- Breaded Raviolis$7.25
- Stuffed Knots$1.68 eachTomato or roasted peppers with prosciutto & fresh mozzarella
- Meatballs (2)$6.18Served with tomato sauce
- Italian Sausage (2)$6.18Served with tomato sauce
- Chicken Wings6 for $8.30 · 12 for $15.55Mild, BBQ, hot or plain. Served with a side of bleu cheese
- Mozzarella Sticks$8.30Served with marinara sauce
- Rice Balls$6.75Filled with meat, peas, onions, and cheese. Add cheese & sauce +$1.05
- Garlic Bread$2.35
- Garlic Bread Parm$3.65Served with tomato sauce
- Zeppoles6 for $4.15 · 12 for $6.25
- Garlic Knots3 for $1.72 · 6 for $4.80 · 12 for $7.25
- Chicken Fingers6 for $8.30 · 12 for $15.55
Soups & Salads
- Tossed Garden Salad$10.20Lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers, olives
- Antipasto Salad$11.95Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, carrots, cauliflower, peppers, and olives
- Scungilli or Calamari Salad$11.40Tender scungilli or calamari on a bed of lettuce with celery, olives, and tomatoes, served cold
- Caesar SaladSmall $8.25 · Large $10.80Romaine lettuce, grated romano cheese, cherry tomatoes
- Greek SaladSmall $8.25 · Large $11.85Lettuce, tomato, onions, olives, carrots, cucumbers, red cabbage, and fresh feta
- Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Basil$10.40In olive oil
- Chicken Bacon Cheddar SaladSmall $9.35 · Large $12.45Lettuce, tomato, bacon, onion, cheddar, cucumber & crispy chicken
- Italian Chef SaladSmall $9.35 · Large $12.45Romaine lettuce, salami, provolone, pepperoni, roasted peppers, olives & capers. Add grilled chicken +$3.50, add cheese +$2.60
- Pasta FagioliSmall $8.30 · Large $13.40
- Lentil SoupSmall $8.30 · Large $13.40
- Chicken SoupSmall $8.30 · Large $13.40
- StraciatellaSmall $8.30 · Large $13.40
- Seafood BisqueSmall $9.35 · Large $14.45
Heros
Extra cheese on any hero +$1.00.
- Meatball$9.85
- Meatballs & Peppers$10.90
- Meatball Parmigiana$10.90
- Sausage$10.40
- Sausage & Peppers$11.40
- Sausage Parmigiana$11.55
- Sausage & Potatoes$11.40
- Veal Cutlet Parmigiana$13.50
- Veal & Peppers$12.45
- Veal & Peppers Parm$13.50
- Veal & Mushrooms$13.50
- Veal & Mushrooms Parm$13.50
- Potatoes & Egg$9.35
- Pepper & Egg$9.35
- Shrimp Parmigiana$14.50
- Eggplant Parmigiana$11.40
- Cold Italian (Boar's Head)$12.20
- Chicken Club$11.85
- Chicken Parmigiana$12.45
- Buffalo Chicken Parm$12.45
- BBQ Chicken Parmigiana$12.45
- Chicken, Bacon, Cheddar & Ranch$12.45
- Fresh Mozzarella, Basil & Tomato on Garlic Bread$10.40
- Broccoli Rabe Parm (Chicken or Sausage)$12.45
- Chicken Francese Parm$12.45
Chicken Entrées
Served with pasta & soup or salad. Pasta choices: Bowtie, Penne, Angel Hair, Spaghetti, Linguini, Fettuccine, Rigatoni, Whole Wheat Penne.
- Chicken Marsala$20.75Chicken sautéed with mushrooms in marsala wine sauce and prosciutto
- Chicken Francese$20.75Chicken breast dipped in egg batter and sautéed in a wine and lemon sauce
- Chicken Piccata$20.75Chicken breast delicately sautéed with white wine, lemon & artichoke hearts
- Chicken Scarpariello$20.75Chicken breast and sweet Italian sausage delicately sautéed with a lemon, garlic & wine sauce
- Chicken Sorrentino$20.75Chicken sautéed in white wine topped with prosciutto, sliced tomato & mozzarella
- Chicken Mediterranean$20.75Chicken, eggplant, diced tomatoes & zucchini sautéed in chunk tomato and wine sauce, topped with mozzarella
- Chicken Parmigiana$20.75Chicken delicately sautéed and covered with mozzarella & tomato sauce
- Chicken Rollatini$20.75Breast of chicken rolled with cheese, ham & assorted seasonings, cooked in a wine sauce with mushrooms
- Chicken Cacciatore$20.75Chicken breast cooked with onions and peppers sautéed in a plum tomato sauce and a splash of wine
Veal Entrées
Served with pasta & soup or salad. Pasta choices: Bowtie, Penne, Angel Hair, Spaghetti, Linguini, Fettuccine, Rigatoni, Whole Wheat Penne.
- Veal Rollatini$22.80Veal cutlet rolled with cheese, ham & seasonings, cooked in a delicate wine sauce with mushrooms
- Veal Francese$22.80Veal dipped in egg batter and sautéed in a wine and lemon sauce
- Veal Cacciatore$22.80Veal cooked with onions, mushrooms & peppers, sautéed with plum tomatoes and a splash of wine
- Veal Marsala$22.80Veal sautéed with mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce and prosciutto
- Veal Parmigiana$22.80Veal sautéed and covered with mozzarella & tomato sauce
- Veal Piccata$22.80Veal delicately sautéed with white wine, lemon & artichoke hearts
- Veal Sorrentino$22.80Veal sautéed in white wine, topped with prosciutto, sliced tomato & mozzarella
Italian Favorites
Served with pasta & soup or salad.
- Chicken & Sausage Campagnola$19.70Chicken breast & sweet Italian sausage fried with sweet peppers, potatoes, onions and hot vinegar peppers
- Eggplant Parmigiana$19.70Eggplant delicately sautéed & covered with mozzarella and sauce
- Eggplant Rollatini$19.70Tender eggplant stuffed with our own seasonings, ricotta & mozzarella
- Sausage & Peppers Parm$18.65
- Carlo's Delight$18.65Combination of lasagna, stuffed eggplant & veal cutlet parmigiana
- Carlo's Special$18.65Combination of veal cutlet parmigiana & eggplant parmigiana
- Carlo's Italian Surf & Turf$23.85Golden fried shrimp & tender veal cutlet in our special marinara sauce, covered with mozzarella cheese
- Pasta Pleasure Combo$20.70Stuffed shells, ravioli, and manicotti
Pasta Dishes
Served with soup or salad.
- Baked Ziti$18.00
- Lasagna (Homemade)$18.00
- Manicotti (Homemade)$18.00
- Stuffed Shells Parm (Homemade)$18.00
- Ravioli Parmigiana$18.00Stuffed with cheese
- Lobster Ravioli$19.70Choice of alfredo, vodka, or marinara
- Tortellini Alfredo$18.66White cream sauce
- Rigatoni with Meat Sauce$21.20Our tomato sauce with ground beef
- Spaghetti with Broccoli$18.60Sautéed with garlic and oil
- Linguini Carretiere$17.50Fresh tomatoes, basil, garlic & olive oil
- Penne Arrabiata$17.50Garlic & hot cherry peppers in a spicy marinara sauce
- Penne alla Vodka$21.80Penne pasta in a pink creamy vodka sauce with red onions and ham
- Fettuccine Alfredo$19.80Fettuccine pasta in a creamy alfredo sauce
- Fettuccine Carbonara$20.85Prosciutto & peas in a white cream sauce with mozzarella on top
- Fettuccine Primavera$19.80Mushrooms, onions, broccoli, peppers, zucchini, and basil in a pink cream sauce
- Linguini Puttanesca$18.60Fresh tomatoes, garlic, capers, olives & anchovies
- Linguini with Clam Sauce$20.85Seasoned clam sauce, red or white, with garlic
- Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce$13.55Topped with our original tomato sauce
- Penne Alfredo with Chicken$24.30Pasta in a creamy alfredo sauce with sautéed chicken breast, fresh tomato, and peas
- Linguini con Broccoli Rabe$20.85Sauteed broccoli rabe, sweet Italian sausage, garlic & oil over linguini
- Pasta with Meatballs or Sausage (2)$19.75Linguini pasta topped with our tomato sauce, with meatballs or sausage
- Bow-Tie Pasta with Crab Meat$19.75Bow-tie pasta with onion and sun-dried tomato in a pink cream sauce
- Bow-Tie Pasta with Gorgonzola Cheese$19.75Bow-tie pasta with sun-dried tomatoes, prosciutto & mushrooms in a light pink sauce
- Rigatoni Boscaiola$19.75Rigatoni with sun-dried tomatoes, prosciutto, onions, and mushrooms served in tomato sauce with cognac and cream
Paninis
- Grilled Chicken, Roasted Peppers & Fresh Mozzarella$8.30
- Mushrooms, Roasted Peppers & Fresh Mozzarella$8.30
- Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Fresh Mozzarella$8.30
- Eggplant, Roasted Peppers & Fresh Mozzarella$8.30
Sides
- Spinach or Broccoli$8.30
- French Fries$4.15
- Onion Rings$4.15
- Grilled Chicken$8.80
- Side of Sauce4oz $1.15 · 8oz $2.33 · 16oz $3.90
- Alfredo Sauce (16oz)$6.75
- Vodka Sauce (16oz)$6.75
Seafood
Served with pasta & soup or salad.
- Mussels Marinara or Bianco$20.75Mussels served in your choice of sauce
- Calamari or Scungilli Marinara$22.80Fresh squid or conch sauteed in our marinara sauce
- Seafood Scampi Combo$31.00Shrimp and lobster tail, sautéed in butter, garlic & white wine
- Seafood Terrano$28.00Lobster tail & shrimp sautéed in a marinara sauce
- Pescatore$27.00Shrimp, calamari, clams & mussels in a light marinara sauce
- Zuppa di Pesce$35.00Shrimp, scungilli, calamari, clams, mussels & lobster cooked together in a spicy, light marinara sauce
- Seafood Fra Diavolo alla Carlo$22.70Shrimp in a spicy marinara sauce served with mussels & clams
Shrimp Entrées
Served with pasta & soup or salad.
- Shrimp Marinara$22.80Shrimp sautéed in our marinara sauce
- Shrimp Parmigiana$22.80Shrimp breaded, topped with mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce
- Shrimp Farfalle$22.80Shrimp combined with garlic, broccoli rabe & sun-dried tomatoes and sauteed in olive oil & white wine
- Shrimp Oreganata$22.80Shrimp topped with seasoned bread crumbs in a light sauce of butter, garlic & white wine
- Shrimp Scampi$22.80Shrimp in garlic, butter & wine sauce
- Shrimp Alfredo$22.80Shrimp sautéed in a creamy alfredo sauce
- Shrimp Piccata$22.80Shrimp sautéed with artichoke hearts with white wine, lemon, and butter
- Shrimp with Garlic & Oil$22.80Shrimp sautéed and seasoned in garlic & oil sauce
- Shrimp Fra Diavolo$22.80Shrimp in a spicy marinara sauce
- Shrimp in Pesto$22.80Shrimp sautéed in a creamy pesto sauce
- Stuffed Shrimp$22.80Shrimp stuffed with a crab meat filling
- Stuffed Francese$22.80Dipped in egg-batter and sautéed in a lemon wine sauce
Rolls & Calzones
- Chicken Roll$8.30
- Sausage Roll$8.30
- Calzone (with sauce)$6.75
- Calzone (with ham & sauce)$8.30
- Deep Fried Calzone$6.75
- Spinach Wheel$3.70
- Pepperoni Wheel$3.70
- Family Calzone$16.35
- Family Calzone (with ham & sauce)$19.35
Children's Menu
For children 12 and younger.
- Spaghetti & Meatball (1)$10.30
- Baked Ziti$10.30
- Ravioli (Cheese)$10.30
- Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana with Pasta$11.35
- Chicken Fingers with French Fries$10.30
- Spaghetti & Tomato Sauce$8.60
Dessert
- CannoliAsk in store
Please note: Prices subject to change. All menu prices reflect our standard rate for card payments. As an incentive, we offer a 3.75% discount for all transactions paid in cash. Call (631) 924-8760 to confirm. Ready to order? Call us for pickup, or get it delivered through DoorDash, Grubhub, or Uber Eats.